Category: Uncategorized

  • Hola Cata

    Como estas

    Hola

    Ale

  • The question is if one considers layout as content or not

    That sentence is basically the whole argument in one line.

    Whether WordPress is a CMS or a site builder comes down to this:

    Is layout itself content?


    If layout is content

    Then Gutenberg is right.

    A “page” is not:

    title: About Us
    body: We are a company founded in 1998…
    

    but:

    • a hero block
    • followed by a 3-column feature grid
    • followed by testimonials
    • followed by a CTA banner

    In that worldview:

    • Layout is meaningful information.
    • The page is its visual structure.
    • Content is not reusable — it is authored for this exact page.

    This is how marketing teams actually think.

    So WordPress becomes a correct CMS for marketing websites.


    If layout is not content

    Then Directus is right.

    “About Us” is:

    company_founded_year: 1998
    mission_statement: …
    team_members: […]
    

    And layout is:

    • A projection of that data
    • A rendering concern
    • A frontend problem

    In that worldview:

    • Content must survive redesigns.
    • Layout must be disposable.
    • A website is just one consumer of your content.

    This is how engineers think.

    So Directus is a correct CMS for information systems.


    Why mixing them breaks everything

    The trouble is WordPress tries to live in both worlds:

    • It stores layout as content
    • While still pretending content is reusable

    So you get:

    • Blocks embedded in HTML
    • Content that only renders properly in its original theme
    • Exports that are meaningless without Gutenberg

    It violates both models:

    • Not clean enough for CMS purity
    • Not clean enough for builder simplicity

    The real divide

    This is not about tools.

    It’s about whether your organisation believes:

    “A page is a designed artefact”
    or
    “A page is a view over data”.

    WordPress chose the first.
    Directus chose the second.

    Neither is wrong — but once you choose, you can’t pretend the other one still holds.